[tex-live] your eqexam package
Philip Taylor (Webmaster, Ret'd)
P.Taylor at Rhul.Ac.Uk
Fri Jul 9 12:25:26 CEST 2010
T T wrote:
Master/tlpkg/bin/tl-update-docindex in our repository.
>> 2) What would you define as the "source" for the
>> attached file  ? In my opinion, the "source"
>> is an evanescent sequence of keystrokes, since
>> there is no physical copy other than the PDF.
>> ** Phil.
>>  This file was created in Open Office Writer,
>> and the PDF generated by OOW's "Export as PDF".
> Oh, please Phil, don't make it harder than it is. The source is not
> some mythical animal no one has ever seen. If you use OOWriter to
> produce the PDF, then the .odt file is the source. If you would
> hand-craft that PDF, then the PDF is the source. I don't think there
> is any ambiguity here (at least I don't see it).
I'm not trying to "make it harder than it is" : I'm trying
to point out that the "source" for a document is an
extraordinarily hard thing to define, and that we must
therefore be flexible in terms of our requirements rather
than rigid as at present. There /is/ no .odt file for
the PDF which I circulated, nor has there ever been,
nor will there ever be : it is clearly possible to go
from an evanescent sequence of keystrokes to a final
PDF file without there ever being a physical instantiation
of a corresponding source document.
Don Story and Ulrike Fisher's work is clearly of interest
and benefit to the TeX community : if they prefer to
offer only a final PDF rather than their own personal
sources for that PDF, then that should (IMHO) be more
than sufficient to allow the inclusion of their work
in TeX Live.
More information about the tex-live